User:Cheezperson/tier talk

Cheezperson's tier commentary
These are my views. Discussion on talk page is to be strictly about my views, as there is already a forum page made for general discussion of the tiers.

But first, here it is, brawl tier list 2.0


 * "S" tiers: I like the idea of making a separate tier for Meta Knight and Snake, but I don't think that Meta Knight is that good. He's on top, Snakes number 2, but I think they warrant a class to share.


 * "A" tier: I don't like Falco above Dedede and Game&Watch, but that's just me. I'm gald to see Marth and Diddy (especially Diddy) move up, but putting them above R.O.B. is something that I disagree with.


 * "B" tier: Needs to include more characters. I like the positioning here, especially having Olimar in it.  Donkey Kong should belong to this tier, as should Toon Link and Kirby.


 * "C" tier: I hate Pikachu. It only has a few decent moves, plus thunder.  I don't see what the big buzz is over Pikachu.  All 3 of the other C characters are better.  Also, I believe Wolf and possibly Pit deserve entry in this tier because they are popular, have very usable advanced techniques, and both have solid ground and aerial games (not the best recoveries, though).


 * "D" tier: Biggest mistake made here: Zero Suit Samus above Toon Link, Pit, and Wolf. ZSS's recovery is just as easily gimped as Pit's and Wolf's.  Toon Link being this low is part of the reason I main him, he's so underappreciated.  He's got a great recovery, solid projectiles, a combo-oriented aerial game, and some of the best overall smashes in the game.  Peach belongs here, but so should Luigi, Fox, and Zelda.


 * "E" tier: Wow, Zelda and Fox got jipped in this tier list. They were high in the first one, but man, that's too big a drop.  Luigi's got such a great aerial game, only surpassed by Meta Knight in terms of combo-ability.  It's only a matter of time before someone comes up with some 0-death combos with him.  Lucas should be here.


 * "F" tier: Mario and Ness deserve spots here (at the top). Lucas's positioning is a crime, but other than that, I like it. I do think that Pokemon Trainer has more potential and will rise in later lists, but for now, I liek it.


 * "G" tier: Bottom of the barrel... try as you may, Captain Falcon got bottom 2 times in a row. The good things about these characters is that they gain popularity just by being bottom tier, and that may spark some brawlers to try them out and prove that these characters are better than what they appear.  Someone has to be on the bottom, and these 4 are the bottom.  Samus, in my opinion, should be in this tier, below Link, because Link is better at Ko'ing.

Well, that's it. This is part 1, so expect more depth later.