Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-24114180-20140107193454/@comment-10583149-20140929222702

Nope, not even close.

The Ganondorf would get bodied because the match-up is terrible regardless. Also, the odds of finding 2 people with the exact same skill is astronomically low.

The players aren't merely pushing buttons. There are mindgames, predictions, strategies, all kinds of things. Strategy matters, but there are characters that are better than others.